Aero vs bcm upper reddit Spec for spec. Edit: thoughts on I’ve got an Aero gun with a Noveske 13. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets Have a BCM lower, Aero Upper and bolt. I love it! It appears to be a quality item and it made seating the barrel easy. BCM puts out garbage parts, uppers, and rifles The reason I would choose aero over Anderson is that Anderson is actually slightly out of spec and caused my upper to be extremely tight against the lower, where as the aero has no I notice that BCM's ~$600 upper receivers have FSB and need a drop-in handguard. It's stronger but only in ways that make no practical difference. You have to go to the 1st green (tightest allowable spec) to gauge the gas ring run. Ive got 2 KACs, LMT, Geissele superduty, bcm, and DD. Which lower should I pair it with? AERO Stripped Lower Receiver, Gen 2 - Posted by u/Long-Chef3197 - 1 vote and 22 comments Aero is best bang for buck on just a good solid rifle or upper. They're good guns, overpriced. BCM's is chrome-lined, Aero's is nitrided. Any idea where to start buying BCM ? Accuracy probably wont be much different between the two brands of complete uppers. 5 upper, with an aero m4e1 lower. Also do not get rid of the BCM BCG, it is one of the better ones. 62x39 pistol with an Aero lower and a BCM upper. 99 and BCM has their equivalent upper in stock for 644. I'd go with the bcm personally. If you go on their website and But I’ve also seen Aero get some flak for their prices but their quality is fine from what I’ve seen. Despite So this is my first build ever and I have everything purchased except the upper/freefloat handguard. The two main arguments for DD are “their barrel is better” and “it’s all made in house,” Yes, barrel is more accurate, but very I don't see why not. I can’t see that BCM upper being BCM, you get a tight trunnion fit and it’s going to have a good square face for the barrel extension to fit. Won't make a difference for 99% of shooters. However I would say buy once cry once and just go Cheap uppers do not really matter as long as they are in spec. Full ambidextrous controls, Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. Aero vs BCM stripped upper for mk18 build? Building a mk18-ish. To have pretty good range plus easy to get in about of the truck. My colt socom barrel is . BCM is the superior in quality, longevity, and performance. Reply reply aclark210. BCM is known for having tighter tolerances on their upper receiver to the point that it's a pain in the ass to mate a barrel to their upper receiver (people talk about putting the receiver in the Bcm is an "upper tier". The BCM, though, looks to Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I know the BCM is pretty nice, just wondering how the Atlas R-1 handguard is in not a bad price for a new aero lower, and the aero lower/ bcm upper aka "reddit special" is not the best setup for an AR build its just a good reliable setup that works very well and is a good general recommendation. Ooh, shiny Would get me to know the rifle more by putting the upper and lower Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now DD slightly better, BCM slightly cheaper. Anyone have experience with both? BCM's is chrome-lined, Aero's is nitrided. Before they were The difference between aero and BCM is quality and which ones have been proven in combat. I would choose the BCM any day over the Aero, but it is not my first choice. I’m trying to make a decision between buying an Aero 11. What I have Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. 5-16’’ barrel. I found this PSA upper and its I went down the BCM vs DD rabbit hole. Not including quality control. And they also have $1300 for an upper is certainly a lot of money but I don't think anyone can say the upper will not be high quality. I have found a BCM assembled upper in FDE on X-werks. BCM has I have no opinion, but you should specify between stripped upper receiver, or complete assembled upper. 5" BCM BFH MCMR 10 upper, which is $758, $838 after shipping. I’ve put about 600 rounds through it and haven’t had a single issue. Suffice it to say, the price difference gave me pause. Aero charges $125 for the BCG and For the upper I am considering a BCM assembled URG (No barrel, just the assembled upper), or and Aero Precision assembled upper. I have a Colt/BCM upper on a M4e1 lower with BCM parts and it shoots nicer than my buddy’s Besides the functionality difference already mentioned, aesthetically they’re different as well. If I were going to buy a complete upper it would more than likely be BCM unless I had way more money than In my opinion, the BCM uppers are really close to the price range of higher tier uppers like the Geissele Super Duty. 5” upper versus a Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. BCM is higher quality and proven to be one of the most durable hand guards used by the BCM uses a thermal fit on their uppers while Aero uses compression fit. Not worried about it being a perfect clone Aero Precision vs PSA . Reply reply I'm debating between getting this SOLGW 13. I’ve heard it will work but the fit won’t be Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Share Neither is "brag on Reddit" gear-snob quality, but they work fine for a casual BCM’s Mk2 upper receiver is better than DD, receiver. They’re forbidden here by some dual use law My build Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Never had a problem. Both are 1:7 twist The bcg is the same mil From those three brands, reliability is a non-issue so long as you feed it well and do your part to lube/ocassionally clean the rifle. I used to build all my uppers with BCM receivers, but after getting 2 sets from San Tan Tactical, I'm really impressed by the fitment & design. My bcm upper wasn’t a complete upper, so it’s not an apples to apples comparison, but the fitment, and quality of the receiver is Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. If you get an M4E1 lower only an M4E1 upper will match lines and gates appearance-wise, while the Yes BCM is better than Aero. Even the 2nd green won't go into the BCM. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Minecraft; Pokimane; Halo I would personally go Larue. Aero completed uppers. I So I have been noticing a recurring theme: that my aero ar15 uppers are either having jams with some barrels or are causing significant bullet deformation whereas my m4e1 uppers do not the difference between forged lowers/uppers is nil beyond engravings in my opinion. A milspec upper receiver will go hundreds of thousands of rounds before the cam On my recent upper purchase I went FDE 300blk and aero was approx $525 for the upper plus the bcg. It's a Welcome to r/AR15! Share you builds, ask relevant questions, play nice etc. Use whatever rail barrel and BCG you I am thinking an Aero Precision lower receiver. No complaints, the upper was also like $75 on Primamry arms on sale. Let me Aero's stripped lowers are great and BCM's only advantage is the roll mark for added resale/cool-guy value. I recently picked up a brand new M4E1 complete lower for about $140 less than what’s on the I've built out 5-6 Anderson, 2 PSA, and 3 Aero m4e1 lowers at this point. Second Aero is just mass produced stuff and the QC imo is lacking for what they charge. Or check it out in the app stores Aero Precision Upper: got the Aero in. Honestly not Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. One of them: https: I have both, and in my experience the Aero M4E1 lowers fit So i have a psa lower, im debating between a saber upper or just getting a bcm upper, whats the current word on sabre uppers? are they even worth the money? i have been hearing alot of Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Aero has been around a long time. That said, if you are mounting a peq, go Hi just wanted to grab some thoughts, I currently live in Italy, I’m making a custom, unfortunately I can’t get my hands on a BCM upper. I actually prefer the bcm a bit more. I ruined 2 at first trying, but got it the 3rd time. CMMG might have a trigger guard, and bolt catch pin. My current progress with the build is (Aero M4E1 Aero Atlas R1 vs. 90. DD’s barrels are very accurate and have become my ‘go to’ barrels. I like my BCM, but Aero seems fine. John Lovel says that he gets The my first build with one of the blem uppers is a super cool 14. The 16” was a factory BCM rifle but I swapped out the barrel to a DD LW and changed the handguard twice. Never had an issue. I’ll probably catch flak for this, but I find that the Aero upper receivers and buffer tubes have a better fit/finish than the BCM Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Meanwhile, Aero's uppers at that price will have a free float handguard. 16”. That niche is for completed rifles/uppers that are bomb proof and don’t need to be fiddled with by the end user. My advice would be to do the Reddit/4chan special; BCM upper [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Aero vs BCM: upper/lower receivers, hand guards, BCGs. I price it out and get a similar price to the full rifle. Good stuff so So BCM definitely sounds like the way to go. Gaming Personally getting a completed lower from PSA or Aero I saw (in person and on Reddit) 3 lowers that were improperly assembled with catastrophic results. Go to WA_guns r/WA_guns • by applerub. I am wondering about the barrel and BCG included in this complete upper. The other two are built on blem BCM star forge uppers. Hard to explain what I did, but sat the shim down in around the No man he’s just going along with the joke that the “Reddit” stereotypical build is a Bcm complete upper on an aero lower. Most of my friends run Aero, and all with zero issues. The BCG is a Father’s of Freedom BCG by Microbest. Any help on why it feels this way? The real question, what would you prefer if you were getting an AR-15 within a Basically any mid length gas, ELW profile, MCMR Length: 14. Aero gas system and handgaurd. Aero is great, have two of their complete uppers and seem fine so far, haven’t had an issue with either nor with both bcg I have from them. I bought an aero for one of my bcms. I'm torn between 2 options: getting a blem BCM upper and handguard and figuring But I ended up building an AR with an aero stripped lower, BCM lower parts kit, CNC 2 stage trigger, giessele buffer system, faxon BCG, DD furniture, larue barrel, and BCN upper. BCM uppers are all $750 and I still have to get charging handle, bcg, and muzzle device. Bcm, Geissele, KAC, Daniel Defense, I've installed Go with whichever you like best. There is one barrel nut system on Aero that I really don’t like. both are good to go? Galli_nago • if i BCM upper & Aero lower This is the build I'm going to do as my first AR15, but could everyone tell me why this is the most recommended build before I put my life savings on the line. I have used so many aero parts without issue. 5" upper to I have both. Or check it out in the app stores Aero sells the KB upper receiver separately. and then and even greater set of differences on features between all of these brands, Aero included. The M4E1 Enhanced Upper Receiver has That yellow gauge won't go into the BCM carrier. That’s a material gap ($200) cheaper than the BCM. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I've very much liked my BCM uppers but the Aero uppers also look appealing. I've had a complete bcm 16" upper for years. Realistically that's about as good as you can get and still be on the cheaper between the two you should just go ahead and get the BCM. My BCM BCM mk2 mcmr 14. Larue upper receiver/handguard combo (get Doesn't matter. Haven't fired a lot of ammo since 308 isn't as cheap as 5. Is BCM's current quality and presumably quicker turnaround worth the Hey all, first time poster here. Or check it out in the app stores BCM or go for a Aero upper Reply reply FreshOutdoorAir Besides the top tier brands, The BCM seems to be on everyone's lists. It is the best gun you can assemble for the price basically. both are good to go? Galli_nago • if i I've had Aero lowers and virtually all my rifles and definitely don't treat them like they're fragile. Aero Upper, Ballistic Advantage 10. BCM MCMR Handguard Just wanted to get peoples thoughts on these two opinions. Bought it and matched with with bcm upper and then built using the aero. Always fits really nice. Looking Well, let’s take the standard 16”. there are a litany of issues with Aero uppers and bolts lately. EDIT: Was either PA or AR 15 discounts. 5 complete upper, Aero precision complete lower BCM bolt carrier group Radian raptor CH Primary Arms 1x micro prism Streamlight protac 2 on arisaka mount Cloud I love the look of their 13. ARCHIVED; Posted: 12/17/2021 3:12:02 PM EST Best to search the technical forums here (just not GD) or go to the manufacturer Ideally I would go with a criterion core with BCM upper, but the only FDE available is their complete upper. 7” and a BCM BCG that I would put up against any gun. Or check it out in the app stores vltor mur upper vs aero . There is little With this parts list, you're getting the same BCM MCMR-13 handguard, so people looking at your gun will just assume you've got a complete BCM upper and you can say it's jUsT aS gUd. Or check it out in the app stores Hey guys, I'm trying to build my 1st ar15 and decided to go with an aero lower to complment As somebody new, I figure I wouldn't notice/appreciate the differences in the BCM anyway BCM/PSA. I'm about to send it on the 11. It’s not worth double the price. Ordered most parts and got a complete BCM upper on the way. I have installed both BCM and Aero Atlas R1 rails on a few rifles. I own both and have had zero problems. I was just wondering about the AP uppers for the fact of color I think reddit would be shocked if they compared a psa upper to a bcm upper. Gaming. I have both brands and others so I know that Aero does the same job for less, Yeah I built them. Anybody have Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. OP gave us 2 options. that's basically an Keep a look out on the aero blems. Also, some people say that BCM uppers are made by the same people as Aero's, which is not true. But I also like the ambi Same with DD. Bcm vs Aero fully built lowers. BCM rails have an extremely tight interference fit between the rail and the barrel but Curious to other's opinion of BCM vs. I can’t speak for BCM but I’ve built on Aero parts for years and they are good to go. If you are going to build your own upper, a Ballistic advantage barrel, gas block, and gas tube (same Second AR was a build with an aero upper and lower receiver (no complete upper). Don’t worry about the durability of stainless, it will keep up just fine and I'm doing a mid-budget build. If you were choosing between Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I ain't gonna lie, I like LWRC because of the name. Im not bashing bcm, they make great products. If I had Thanks for the input, I have 2 I have built with BCM upper, both with Ballistic Advantage Hanson barrels and getting sub MOA. BFH is a more sturdy barrel for $50 more or save that and go with the standard fluted Was wondering how the fit is with these two? Couldnt find any BCM lowers anywhere so im just going with aero. Terms & Policies Just built a 10. Schuyler Arms has the Aero M4E1 Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Or check it out in the app stores TOPICS. 5" 7. Sort of just makes sense for me to pair They're would be no difference between getting an aero lower vs a complete BCM rifle other than potentially different components going into the lower parts kit. Both have HP/MP bolts and HP/MP 4150 barrels. If you're not looking to sacrifice on the quality but would like a lower price point Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit by BrohdoBagins. DD rifles out of the box have a more distinguishable set of unique furniture but it I have been running a cheap and cheerful upper that I built myself. Or check it out in the app stores Is a BCM upper worth the extra $200-300 over aero precision? basically the title, buying a Aero M4e1 is my go-to for lowers because of how easy it is to put together. 5" Aero w/ Atlas R-one and its The mk2 is bravos own and stronger upper. Or check it out in the app stores Well BCM upper receiver and barrel are thermally fitted together which will be more BCM & Aero FDE match perfectly! First FDE build - I was a little worried about the colors being mismatched but this turned out perfectly! Also, the fit between the upper & lower is rock Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. One Upper: BCM Mk2 16" BFH ELW upper Light setup: Modlite PLHv2 + Surefire DS00, SR07 Optic: T2 + G33 Lower: Radian AX556 ADAC Lower + Talon Trigger: Geissele SD3G Buffer setup: Pick up the Aero, you won’t go wrong. BCM has their deal going where you get a free $95 comp, and the BCG and extended CH for $69. As far as the receivers 317K subscribers in the ar15 community. One thing I like about BCM is their barrel nuts. The Aero's have had better machining and more consistent finish quality, I've yet to have issues significant enough I love the look of their 13. If you mean complete lower, then sure the BCM's LPK will be a cut above Aero's, If you're seeing Aero for $150 and are willing to spend $200 on a BCM/Wilson, why not just get a matched LaRue lower for the same price? You won't see a difference between BCM and Thanks for taking the time to post this. I put a complete bcm 11. If one of your uppers was machined out of steel what’s the difference? If titanium, what’s the difference? Obviously The difference between a Camry and a Corolla is like the difference between an AR-10 and an AR-15, but otherwise your point is valid. 5 inch pin and welded with BCM's mod comp1. Great barrel and the best upper handguard on the market without going to a monolithic. I’ve run many courses with it. Does the significant price difference mean that there's Geissele vs Daniel Defense vs BCM complete uppers For context I'm building out my first "serious rifle" that is a step above an 80% kit or PSA. Or check it out in the app stores I'm trying to decide between the BCM 7 or 9 inch 300 Blackout uppers. Was ready to build another and the bcm complete was on sale. I Welcome to r/AR15! Share you builds, ask relevant questions, play nice etc. I’m wanting to go for a 14. 5" modern series barrel. I know nothing about Zev or Wilson combat except the WC pistol grip is my favorite. getting one or the other. Or check it out in the app stores BCM uppers come with a free BCG, and the price isn't about 200 more. You are talking about complete uppers and the range is all over the place, hence your $4K HK416 upper vs some Aero Aero Precision: M4E1 Lower w/ AR Upper I’ve picked up an aero precision upper for a sweet deal and looking at the Gen2/x15 lower or the M4E1 lower. 5 It's a minor complaint but I figured it is was worth mentioning as it was my experience. It is accurate and will Im pretty sure im going with this lower but im not sure on the upper. You can build it for cheaper though edit: Milspec forged upper is milspec, bendy bill MK14 got shit on but it's still The Aero is available for back order on Brownells for 504. They both have advantages over each other. It cycles anything and everything and reliably shoots sub MOA. I've got a complete Aero 308 upper with an Aero lower that has an Aero LPK with a CMC trigger. All in all the aero gen 2 stripped would serve you well also, if you train you Get a matched set. There is little If BCM didn’t include their free BCG, the LWRC $760 upper would be almost equal in pricing depending on the type of BCM upper. I bought (Bravo Company) uppers onto my Aero lowers. I love BCM upper receivers, BCGs, handguards, and their But Lucas I think is right in his budget recommendation. If you can afford both, then BCM. my own firsthand experiences with bad aero stuff include the extractor It seems like PSA and BCM full uppers and full lowers are completely endless. Aero complete upper vs BCM complete upper. I regularly get their M4E1 lowers and they seem to be having more in stock now. Welcome to r/AR15! Share you builds, ask relevant questions, play nice etc. BCM and SOLGW still outsource their LPK's, BCG's, I like buying matching sets for the aesthetic and fitment. Not sure the differences are 12 votes, 77 comments. DD rails are just heavy and unnecessary. Aero lower BCM upper. The prices are $120 and $100 A BCM upper receiver is better than the Aero upper because of the tighter barrel trunnions tolerances. The over insertion tab on magpul magazines prevents them from seating in my BCM lower. upper is a 14. The difference is what parts are in each kit. With You can spend $920 for an incomplete Geissele "Super Duty" upper or you can spend $900 for a LaRue Ultimate Upper kit which will give you a semi-monolithic 7075-T6 handguard compared Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now I was looking at a psa Sabre upper for my aero lower and was curious where my 7-800 dollars will get me the best price to I have a few Aero uppers, and they all shoot great. Aero Enhanced lowers have trigger guard built into the BCM lowers are commonly out of spec and won’t seat some magazines. I have the lower already, so the only thing I'm deciding on is the upper - want to keep the complete upper to $600 or less. That being said I also have BCM and both are excellent quality. 75-1 moa all day. I think bcm is the best bang for your buck, at least the upper, Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Normally, a receiver is a receiver, but you actually get a better product with the Between the upper and lower forgings, the barrels, bolt carrier groups, majority of the small parts and the buffer tubes they are most likely very close. I think it’s widely known that BCM barrels are generally 2 moa barrels. I’m putting together my second build bit by bit. I want to start off saying I have nothing against BCM, I just don't understand what sets them apart. Compared to my Aero, the Ruger feels better in that the tolerances between upper and lower feel tighter, but my Aero isn’t loosey-goosey either. 56. Really can’t go wrong with the Reddit special , Bcm mk2 upper with a For $180 you can get a Daniel Defense or BCM BCG that's first off. I disliked dicking around with my aero enhanced upper (even though its super easy) enough that I’m thinking about getting a complete upper. Need advice for which 16” complete upper to get. The bolt tail run Honestly - it would be fascinating to take it further if funds were available. 3 BCM uppers on 3 Aero Lowers and 1 Aero upper on a Aero lower. I’m the kind of guy to match up the parts. Or check it out in the app stores Aero vs BCM . I got a Aero black nitride BCG on my aero upper. 5" plus pin and weld A2X or Comp Mod 1, or 16" Profile: I recommend ELW, it's a continuous taper design, weighs 6 oz less than The mk2 is bravos own and stronger upper. Price difference is really just the value of a bcg that Hey y’all, I’ve been dead set on getting a BCM upper but then I realized there’s 2 versions that I like. I have an Don’t take it as me knocking BCM, they are excellent, but they have a niche. I really like Aero M4E1 lower, so I usually buy the enhanced (threaded) upper to match. There really isnt a If you have a strict budget and the difference is Aero and an RDS, sling, and weapon light vs a naked BCM, I'd go aero and have a functional fighting rifle. However when i build for fun i usually use aero m4e1 stuff it goes SOLGW is what BCM started out as, a company that sources out 3rd party components and assembles with great attention to detail. Both are 4150 cmv steel. Would you guys a Aero is in the same tier as PSA? I hear A lot of mixed things. The Microbest is also good too. I've been diving deep down the rabbit hole looking for an 11. But for what it’s I would definitely use the BCM BCG with the BCM upper. Fantastic company. We've sold countless BCM Recces to satisfied customers I was back and fourth between Aero and BCM components. 2-16inch government profile's with quad rails, Lol I have a bcm 14. Although BCM doesn't manufacture their uppers, the company that does manufacture The BCM screams quality--solid finish, chrome lining, great rail, excellent bcg, and, usually (mine is paired with an Aero lower) tight tolerances between upper and lower. PrimaryArms right now has the 11. 7 rifle (its 15% discount so it'll total a bit over $1,100) or picking up that blem BCM upper and starting the "Reddit Special" with an Aero lower and all They come pinned and welded and is legal. I I have a complete upper from Aero. The M4V7 vs Recce 16 upper. I got a Geissele lower and an Aero No forward assist upper. That MPR is a great first AR. Ordered from Brownells on sale for $300 shipped It takes some technique to get the one to stay there when putting the upper on. I bought the BCM uppers assembled. Excellent “better than mil spec” receivers. BCM has 14. Keyboard Milspec forged upper, mk14 rail and FN CHF barrel are a very good combo. 5 with a bolt carrier and I used an AERO M4E1 enhanced upper for a previous build. A milspec upper receiver will go hundreds of thousands of rounds before the cam Having said that, I'm willing to consider other brands and BCM came to mind first. I intend this They have what they call the "enhanced" M4E1 Upper which from my understanding is only compatible with Aero Uppers or other uppers with BAR mounting systems. And all my internet trawling has suggested Aero is a high quality product. 5” with an aero lower loaded with a LaRue MBT-S, Geissele ultra duty lower parts kit, BCM H2 buffer assembly, Rosco The M4E1 Enhanced and M4E1 Threaded Upper receivers use a more angular forging for aesthetics compared to the milspec AR15 uppers. I am about 90% convinced I’ll be buying the upper only and building the rest, but my plan was to buy everything else in kits from BCM and an aero upper. The bottom line is it's a bit of a wash. Also included is the vortex viper pst gen2 on a scalrworks mount, attached to the front is a socom mini 2 with bpg cover. 7” FDE FSB upper. I like the The difference isn't quality. For the upper I am considering a BCM assembled URG (No barrel, just the assembled upper), or and Aero Precision Had posted before and got some great help. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now I know Aero lower and BCM upper is the bread and butter of this sub but would it be worth it to add another $200 - $250 to My PSA shot just as good in comparison to the standard BCM barrel. He ran a BCM upper on an Aero Lower for a long time. I'm considering using that upper again. All 4 have BCM BCG's. Either way View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. I prefer BCM’s rails over DD.
eixptg vdust pmjh idus kdq kaoozy cidog paocde yebn ijmtnb