Managing vassal limit ck2 reddit Vassals can in turn distribute lands to vassals of their own, which is called subinfeudation . However I do not know how to effectively manage all the vassals. One of the big problems with managing very large empires (such as a fully restored Rome, or a unified Africa) is that you have to do a lot of vassal consolidation. I've formed all the duchy/Jarldoms I can, but some i still tie on and can't seem to bring the vassal number down. Or never create them in the first place. Make sure my rulers get a high diplomacy stat, will increase vassal limit and vassal opinion of you Take the carousing focus. You can edit one or more of the following parameters by entering a higher number: VASSAL_BASE_LIMIT (the vassal limit for everyone) Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. The thing is, it's very unclear to me what the criteria for this limit are. Strategy on vassals is play at exactly your domain limit as much as possible and if you have to give away land and create vassals try to like, not make an ambitious sadistic dude your vassal. Never had a rebellion. Posted by u/kotodrome - 2 votes and 4 comments Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. ) I've taken it slow, and I'm now roughly 125 years in. Nubia is a singular kingdom, the Sunni Shia have been pushed to Damietta and Sinai Honestly, I wouldn't give them kingdom titles, unless you are really over the vassal limit and there's absolutely no way to deal with it using duchies. Not playing in 769 also helps. . As a dynasty management tool, duchies can benefit your dynasty Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. My vassal limit still allows me for like 5 or 6 more vassals, they're dukes at best for now comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment More posts you may like At a larger level, duchies are a tool for vassal management when you start expanding beyond your vassal limit. Why even make empires anymore when we can just de jure drift entire kingdoms into our primary one, via Legends? I much prefer weaker dukes than managing kings under an emperor. As for increasing the vassal limit through mods, it's very possible. De jure vassals the whole way down or it affects the money chain. My understanding is that the vassal limit was intended to make players give more power to vassals, such as making super-counts and super-dukes. Try and maintain at least High crown authority. A fairly easy way of managing vassal limit is to concentrate power in the hands of a very powerful, singular vassal. You should have the lowest level vassals possible until your start reaching your vassal limit. Meaning, say i break up a dutchy i conquered and that has 4 holdings, i will make sure that i will grant it to individual vassals, then each lord will be given to one particular duke. Engage in courtly intrigue, dynastic struggles, and holy warfare in mediæval Europe, Africa, the Middle East, India, the steppes and Tibet. The Reichskrone, Iron Crown of Lombardy, and Crown of Justinian are all historical artifacts that have static effects of increasing your vassal limit by 25 (for the Reichskrone) and 10 (for the other two) - and you don't need to play as the HRE or otherwise to get these. For example, rename it defines. Ideally, no vassal should control more than 25% of the total number of counties in your realm. I'm struggling with the vassal limit. only when you reach vassal limit should you grant lands to kings. It will make a character with your religion and culture. If you get your taxes up to 70-100% and drain the entire vassal income, and if your vassals hold their holdings directly (without sub-vassals), your income becomes unreal. Unless you want to manage their succession manually their domain will split into a lot of indirect vassals aswell. I am new to the game and i kind off dont understand the concept of granting vassals to other vassals since it makes them be above domain limit hence they pay less Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. You just need to appease a few kings opposed to dozens of dukes. Vassal limit is a high concern to be worried about. If you have a vassal limit of, say, 20, that is 20 vassals regardless of rank, so 20 counts, or 20 dukes. I'm now 30 over my limit of 60. What I mean by safe vassal limit buffer is that if my vassal limit is 35, I try to keep my current vassal counter at around 31-32. Higher level titles are only for consolidating vassals to have room for even more vassals. You can use it to increase the vassal limit. As soon as a dangerous faction forms I look up what the strongest members want and give it to them. Title distribution strategy is something you should put some thought and effort into. Go toin \Crusader Kings II\common folder Make a backup copy of the file that is named defines. Kingdom titles for me alone. It's like holding 2k holdings personally, you can guess how absurd your money gets with that. This will get you the money needed to create a kingdom title to raise your vassal limit and create dutchies to transfer vassal control to your vassals. If you need to reduce vassals so its under vassal limit, you can always get a nomadic vassal and give all your counties to him while keeping barons under yourself. As a Petty Queen, you should be able to distribute multiple counties/Earldoms to each Earl/Count and that way you can have a domain of 40 or more counties while still holding a Duchy level title and having 20 or fewer vassals, unfortunately you can’t do If you want an empire that big, the new vassal limit essentially gives you no choice but to arrange to have vassals that are individually powerful enough to challenge your rule. MR, I believe, lacks the major later-game increase of the vassal limit. See how long you can manage to stay as a duke and make the biggest custom kingdom you can, you will get insane penalties for vassal limit,county limit etc. Had 15 vassal kings. One of the trickiest things that people seem to get hung up on is how to select new vassals - what traits, how much land to give them, what titles, etc. In CK3, the vassal limit is almost theoretical. That way, I have some leeway in case I need to create another vassal or 2 when I must distribute titles. It made realm management a lot more interesting, even at the empire level. The quarter demesne and vassal limits are a nice touch. There is no easy trick to manage your vassals, nor should there be, in my opinion. Only then do you get into the real fun of CK2: marriage, intrigue, vassal management, succession crises, etc. As for how serious this penalty actually is, the game file defines. Crusader Kings 3 Bug Report Thread - Please post any bugs or issues related to the game, client, and CK3 in Thanks to partition vassal realms will split to the smallest possible unit which is usually the de-jure territory of their primary title. Simply manage your heir count by Celibacy, or marrying old infertile women with good stats. Also, work on increasing your DIP stat if it is lowby adopting the carousing or family focus, but that won't give you more than a 1 or 2 points on your vassal limit. But vassals are worth it, if you do proper realm/vassal management. Choose the carousing focus to increase your DPL. All the time. Grant them to a duke. This should be easy enough to do as vassals get a large bonus towards candidates favored by a king they respect/fear. If nomads are unavailable, you can split your counties between 3 vassals in a way thay they cant make another duchy or kingdom 3. Yes you're right that having Count vassals is generally better for levies/taxes, but if you're Emperor, managing 60+ Counts would be/gets/is ridiculous, and you actually reach a limit of how much you can expand in that case before you must start dishing out titles to Dukes and Kings. After that the game is just boring. Posted by u/osingran - 1 vote and 1 comment Easy. Feel free to visit and share your hype there as well as here. For me, Vassal limit is like price is right rules, as close as you can get to the limit without going over. You hold all empire titles and the kingdom's not dejure to an empire you hold yet and your 2 dutchies / counties worth. Crusader Kings subreddit - r/CrusaderKings is not under the Paradox Plaza network of subreddits, and is therefore a separate community moderated by different moderators. 6. Are you playing ck2? Because in ck 3 I fine vassal management easy. There is a benefit to creating duchies and it is that dukes and above generate their own technology and so contribute to higher technology around your realm. Keep your vassals as counts until you hit your vassal limit. So, around 5 kingdoms you basically have to have 4 king level vassals. Each vassal above whatever limit you have from your title limit is, is 5% less of money and levies from vassal contributions. luaORG Use notepad ++ to open defines. Best to keep the vassal count as close to 60 as possible, but below. This way, your vassal limit is managed but no duke gets too powerful ( their territories become disjointed) and no one duke can claim another dutchy that easily. And I'm kind of in love so far. CK2 limit was much smaller, 20 if I remember. As you conquer lands, make dukes. As a king I am over my current vassal limit, and I am trying to do something about it. Halved demesne is a setting I can't decide on: It makes playing as a lower tier dynasty harder, but it also makes rebellions easier to handle (or I just happened to become better at vassal management). I am not sure if it was implemented in CK3 though The way I deal with messy large empires is to: 1: Consolidate vassals into kingdoms and if possible give them to family members. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. create kingdoms/duchies and give them and the lower titles to your vassals, this way the counts that are part of the duchy/kingdom will become the vassals of the one that controls the kingdom/duchy and wont count as your vassal anymore. So, like probably everyone else, I try to keep my vassal and demensne limits filled to the max. So, once you start building a massive empire, you don't just need a bunch of vassal kings, you need to have vassal kings that control multiple kingdoms. This should be good for one or two vassal limit points over time. I see screenshots in this sub where the Poster has a vassal limit of 50/60+ and I have no idea how it ever gets that high. I conquered the map one. Over Vassal Limit: a percentage depending on the number of vassals in excess of vassal limit. I have wanted to do this for years, but having to deal with all the spawned rebellions, vassal management, and troop limits usually make me give up around the time I have half the map. So now, I am the King of Cockleswhent (region in the Reach), and the King of the North, but I am over the vassal limit 33/32. Vassal limit is to big, which permitted creating of very big empires. Playing different vassal's desires against one another is also a useful strategy. He'll be very happy that you're giving him land and titles. I would only ever do an emperor if I go past the vassal limit! Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Doing this helps reduce your vassal limit, as having dukes in an Empire isn’t ideal unless you have a really high vassal limit. When combined with gavelkind, the vassal limit makes them unplayable, particularly petty kings who start with a very small vassal limit. lua. Yes, I try to beeline to Absolute Rule and Imperial Law for that +25, but after that the council gets power back. I usually have two strategies: The Placeholder Count: My vassal limit is reached. I formed a dutchy title and gave all of the vassals under that title to one man, but that only decreased my vassals by 2 and cost me 170 gold. After taking the vale my vassal limit exploded and now i am wondering how to solve this issue since i cant grant the kingdom of the vale to arryns because it makes them independent. I've created some duchies, but worry about creating really strong ones, especially Barcelona, which is currently my capital, but I'll move to Seville two holy wars in the future and have to give Barcelona to someone. With Conclave and an empowered council, consider appointing powerful vassals to your council to improve opinion and prevent them from factioning once the council is no longer discontent. Jun 12, 2015 · There's no reason to have direct vassal counts if you are a king at your vassal limit. Yes, you'll end up with -95% vassal taxes and -95% vassal levies, but never -100%, and the remaining 5%, plus your personal levies and MaA, will still make you the most powerful ruler on the map. What I always do before granting the county is right click on holding and create a new vassal to rule it. Therefore you have to create Dukes or Kings to reduce the vassal limit. My laws change to reflect that. Feudal gets "Imperial Administration," which is a huge increase to the vassal limit in exchange for a -10 opinion malus to all vassals. Before: Vassals = 3 (3 dukes) Emperor (You) Duke X | Duke Y | Duke Z After: Vassals = 1 (1 king) Jan 30, 2025 · In Crusader Kings II, every vassal can only have 1 liege. You shouldn't do this unless you know you'll die soon, but the trick is this: 1: gain control of the election. Is there no other way than to go through my vassal list and click on each individual vassal and initiate a decision screen? Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Other than that, give out larger titles as a last resort ONLY whenever you hit vassal limit. So in the above scenario, I would right click on the bishopric, create vassal, right click on city, create vassal, and right click on barony, create vassal. If you only control the castle in the capital barony When you hit the empire level and the vassal limit, you'll need to start giving them kingdoms instead of duchies to keep your numbers down since 1 king could have maybe 10 vassal dukes, reducing your vassal limit to just the kings. Go for development map mode in the bottom right and grant the worst lands to kings and keep the best land under dukes. The game is ridiculously easy as long as you avoid these penalties anyways. I guess one advantage was if I won, I usually could imprison and strip titles to gain back land lost in partitions. Here's a tip: with world conquests, if you're at your vassal limit, further subdivide land by having multiple kingdoms per vassal. At 130 and beyond you can safely ignore vassal limit. Thanks to several artifacts Ive managed to bump my vassal limit to 104 and Im still a few over limit. In CK2, when you gave a title, you could also give all of the vassals along with that title. I like to give each viceroy vassal about a de jure empire Shoving vassals under lieges even though they're not de jure part of their domain when needed Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Basically, to answer the other questions just broadly. There is also the option to ask them for a title for 60 prestige. Basically, it's a linear penalty. In CK2 it is in the intrigue menu, i think when your liege has 4+ titles over their demense limit you can offer to help your liege with managing their titles. I have a lot of land but not enough to form the Rus Kingdom with Vladimir and bit of Byzantine empire in my way. THEN you start handing out kingdoms. When you're hitting the vassal limit from having like 50 dukes, check to see if there are any random counts you have as vassals. Half the game i was over the vassal limit but it did not impact me at all. The Vassals you create will be loyal to you at very high opinions. In CK2 there was literally a button that would auto-hand out and create new vassals, because it is so crippling. As MR, retinues and gold (for mercs) are how you grab and hold the majority of your power. Not only will they be forced to centralize their own vassals via vassal kings or superdukes, they'll also likely run over vassal limit almost constantly, which results in vassals gaining independence upon succession. Combination that with instant mobilization - bad game design. But sometimes you get caught up in unexpected situations (usually temporary traits that reduce your stewardship/diplomacy stats that put you over the limit) that demand you to cook up some moves . Let's be honest, your enormous empire is exact what the vassal limit is supposed to make difficult. Vassal Title Management (Important) You dont want vassals to own their own de jure titles, you want them to own titles outside their realm, if they dont get their de jure they will desire it, so give it to a cousin (if not a guy with child) and make them the dukes direct vassal keeping their de jure titles to other counts. I feel my vassal management in Crusader Kings has always been rough. You might reach the vassal limit that you might need king vassals. According to the limit on the right top corner of the screen, I have 16 vassals while I can only have 13. lua has this excerpt: Having a Vassal limit issue. I suppose if you are really desperate you could give more than one title to the same person, but for obvious reasons that can turn against you. Also the raiding unlocks the "Viking" trait which is pretty powerful and will make you more popular with your subjects. At one point, i tried consolidating power in my family, which went well for the current ruler, but succession and civil wars could be dicey. 78% of the counties for the empire of britain sounds like you are just 1 or 2 counties short. But even this only lasts until you become a fairly large Emperor. If all duchies are already handed out, either make some double dukes or transfer loose counts (the ones you can't create the de jure duchy for) to nearby dukes. Your vassal limit is made up of count or higher, non-tribal vassals unless you are tribal yourself, in which case tribal count and above count too. I think it would work out best in the Karl starts, as it should kneecap the Muslim and Byzantine blobs. When you're hitting the limit and can't transfer vassals to fix the problem. Just like there are limits to how much land you can hold, there are limits to how many vassals you can have before maluses start kicking in. ) Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. The numbers are even worse if you're higher rank than Duke. People here talk a lot about a Vassal Limit. Posted by u/kingmoney8133 - 2 votes and 2 comments Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Every single one of those counts are of my dynasty, several being cadet houses that I had to save from extinction after they lost their foreign titles. That is my biggest disappointment in CK3. I would say in your case that a better start might be as a vassal of a larger power, to allow you experience with politicking within a realm and managing fewer and less Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Just finished a game as the bactria empire. Ideally this system should be designed to provide benefits and penalties (or opportunity costs) at all points along the scale, with opposing values at opposite ends of the scale (for example in CK2 low centralization allowed for a large number of vassals, but small demesne limit, while high centralization allowed for few vassals, but high This might be unhelpful because I haven’t played CK2 recently enough to remember if the penalties are the same…but in Ck3 “over vassal limit” has no relationship penalty and caps at 95% loss of vassal taxes/levies…obviously it hurts a lot when you cross the threshold, but you can definitely ignore it once it becomes difficult to keep Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. If you are already a king, then emperor rank will give you an increase. (HRE, Byzantines, or any Empire that gets the Imperial Administration passed) Ideally if you are feudal you can get your personal holdings to be one duchy with 2-3 castles per county, ideally about 7-8 demesne size. I tried giving away smaller titles to lower vassals, but it won't go down. Due to how domain limit works, you want to try to keep the best counties for yourself and have vassals for the crappier ones. I try and get it below 5% and just have a ton of dukes and ride near my vassal limit. If someone doesn't understand basic game mechanics, there is no other way to deal with being over the limit. What the hell? Teching up to Majesty V for the Imperial admin (+25 to vassal limit) Being the HRE (+20 to vassal limit) Piling several viceroyalty kingdoms on a single vassal. This is because having dukes and counts outside of your main kingdom is objectively worse than having kings when you've reached vassal limit, not only because they take up your vassal limit, but also because there is a huge penalty for not being their rightful liege. 20 vassals above is enough to completely axe ALL contributions. Is there a guide (or any helpful tips) for granting/retracting vassals and getting under the 60 vassal limit for your empire? Help I'm rapidly expanding my empire in my save and pretty quickly went from having ~30 vassals to ~75 after waging/winning a bunch of small holy wars in northern Africa, and am struggling with managing all my vassals Plus, Partition has a +10 vassal opinion over Seniority. I then gave away the Kingdom of the North to a Karstark, and it went down to 20/32, but he is not my vassal now. There's a character modifier called vassal_limit. From what I'm reading it's -5% to both taxes and levies for each vassal over the limit, so if you're a Duke, going 1 vassal over gives you 21 vassals at 95% obligation, which is slightly worse than 20 vassals at 100% obligation. Vassal kings are stronger but less numerous. However, they’re more trouble individually being stronger than dukes but there’s less management. Your DPL skill is a major factor on your vassal limit, the same way STW affects your demesne limit. Creating duchies is thus a way to enable further expansion. Haven't played around much with them, but I imagine it adds a nice challenge. I think CK3 is an easier game overall for a bunch of reasons and needs to be looked at (the devs have acknowledged this and said they want to do something about it), but I feel like vassal relations aren't really easier or harder in either game. Those are the rules of thumb. I would try to get your vassal number down to 20, and then work towards getting enough land to make a Kingdom on either Ireland or Germany. In CK2, I used to love setting the vassal limit to 1/4, forcing myself to maintain a small number of powerful vassals. I might be wrong about that, but I'm pretty sure. I have no idea why. Now I have something like 32 vassals which is over my 24 or so vassal limit. And i always prefer smaller vassals to bigger ones, for example: If I were three vassals over my limit, I would rather create a dutchy to rule 3 counts than create a kingdom to rule 3 dutchies (assuming I had a dutchy to make). Get much larger than the base HRE and you simply can't leave all your vassals at ducal rank - there are a few empires, like India, that are large enough that you're locked out of Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. If you’re making a big blobby empire, you’re going to end up having to make vassal dukes and even vassal kings eventually. I'm trying to raise his diplomacy to compensate, but I'm stuck with my current load diplomacy Byzantine wife until she pops out an heir. The domain Now however I'm faced with a problem: I can't wait any levies from my vassals, Charlemagne is already stupidly over his vassal limit (by like 20). The three major factors that effect vassal limit are rank, diplo rating, and laws. There has to be a better way to knock down my vassal number. Granting one vassal to another is not working as they constantly going to war against each other and still have way too many of them. This, however, does not take into account managing multiple kingdom-level titles, vassal management, or the various Muslim powers to your south. Those are much more difficult to hold directly and you might as well just grant them to a vassal as long as you have a Duke title or higher. Invite one vassal at a time to carousing and there's a good chance that you will become friends with that vassal. Maybe?. This option gives the most in taxes and requires faction to appeal to dozens of rulers. The feudal system is a type of decentralization which makes ruling easier at the expense of personal power. I started off in 769 as the petty King of Makuria with the goal of unifying Nubia and booting the Muslims out of Egypt (and later hopefully Jerusalem, and maybe re-coptify Syria and Armenia if I'm not satisfied. It becomes a question of what type of management do you prefer taking. Alright, so the biggest thing is you don't want to have big vassals. The reason you give titles away is to reduce the number of potential rebelions and to simplify dealing with threats. I am constantly at both vassal and demesne limit. I was raiding and growing, and eventually, I subjugated Norway. Got another guide that was hotly requested on the channel: Managing your Vassals. I converted all of scotland,ireland,denmark,norway,sweden to feudalism by 926 holding everything as a duke doing the Mann & the isles decision. More importantly, it's a good idea to remove your vassals and place your dynasty in their own position, for the dynasty relation boost. Your domain limit is not an indication of how many counties you can control directly, but an indication of how many holdings you can control directly. It is impossible not to be over vassal limit in late game. "Easy" in this case is relative. I always felt that ck3 was a much easier game than ck2 (in a bad way) in that managing your vassals as an independent ruler is way too easy. Barons don't count towards vassal limit, only counts and above, so giving them away wouldn't help. It seems that I'm doing well as I have big enough Empire. qcp pes whr uatyg isvhr qzb ddlzw pqut tfsxu xwwlnv becf sbim stm jtqbx hpif